Jump to content


Photo

Banyan Tree - A closer look

tree questions banyan jsw

  • Please log in to reply
4 replies to this topic

#1 Spider

Spider

    DEC (HL)

  • Administrator
  • 3,486 posts

Posted 24 July 2017 - 02:50 PM

I was looking at this recently with some new and interesting thoughts... First of all lets take a look at the standard 'tree' on the Spectrum:

 

tree_spectrum.png

 

The usual fault here is the earth cell on the right, preventing Willy from climbing the tree.

 

However lets take an alternative view of this, what if that cell was intentional ? As it stands you cannot climb the tree even with the 'head height' concern, from either side. However if you add another earth cell thus:

 

tree_spectrum_extra_block.png

 

You *can* now climb the tree from the left side. It is very difficult to time it correctly however the jump between the platforms means he hits his head on the new earth cell, resulting in him being 'in' the water cells rather than just falling down. Its possible, I've done it.

 

 

Another scenario although this one is very unlikely, how about adding some water cells a bit higher up ? This way he can climb from the left again and pass through to the right...

 

tree_spectrum_sideways.png

 

As I say I think that is very unlikely.

 

A more likely plausible case would be to question why there are currently 'useless' platforms on the left side halfway up. Lets take another scenario instead, assuming the 'single earth cell' in the tree is correct how about just adding a couple of water cell platforms on the left thus:

 

tree_spectrum_extra_sides_platforms.png

 

Now, Willy can climb the tree but only from the Orangery. This seems reasonably plausible as its slightly tricky to reach that area anyway. It also means the ramp on the lower left is more a 'preview of the tree' than anything else. It does mean the right hand platforms are redundant however, but in the same way the left ones are currently.

 

Food for thought (depending on what fruit the tree provides, assuming it is a fruit tree) ;)

 

As a bit of amusement here is a large picture of the tree from a few different platforms. I've only covered the major versions and some variants look so similar (for example the Einstein version looks identical to the Spectrum completely) I left them out. Bear in mind the Spectrum version was obviously first so it was logical they used the same layout, however given the 'hidden / unreachable object' issue as well as things like the 'Conservatory Roof vs fire cell' item, it does not mean what we 'see today' is how it really was intended to be...

 

tree_full.png

 

No prizes for identifying each tree variant though. Finally here are the individual pics from that 'combi' above as it may be easier to view them this way:

 

tree_c64.png tree_amiga.png

 

tree_bbc.png tree_amstrad.png


  • IRF likes this
Changing order to chaos since 1984

#2 IRF

IRF

    Advanced Member

  • Contributor
  • 3,891 posts

Posted 24 July 2017 - 03:20 PM


A more likely plausible case would be to question why there are currently 'useless' platforms on the left side halfway up. Lets take another scenario instead, assuming the 'single earth cell' in the tree is correct how about just adding a couple of water cell platforms on the left [top-left corner of 'A Bit of Tree'] thus... Now, Willy can climb the tree but only from the Orangery.

 

Have you tried it?  I don't think Willy will be able to jump up and land on the single-cell platform in 'Under the Roof' (the one attached to the left-hand side of the 'trunk')?  That single-cell platform is one row too high up, and Willy's Airborne Status Indicator is reset when he jumps up from one room to the next one above, so I believe that he will briefly appear in the bottom-left of 'Under the Roof' but will just fall straight back down again...

 


Food for thought (depending on what fruit the tree provides, assuming it is a fruit tree) ;)

 

Figs, since it's a Banyan Tree. B)



#3 Spider

Spider

    DEC (HL)

  • Administrator
  • 3,486 posts

Posted 24 July 2017 - 03:30 PM

The 'modified' screens were mockups with paint. :) I've not directly tried that method no, perhaps adding a single cell lower down would 'fix' that. I see what you're saying though now.

 

I have tried the 'two earth cell' method though. :thumbsup:


  • IRF likes this
Changing order to chaos since 1984

#4 jetsetdanny

jetsetdanny

    Advanced Member

  • Contributor
  • 1,935 posts

Posted 26 July 2017 - 06:36 PM

Thanks for an interesting analysis and pictures, Andy! :)



#5 Spider

Spider

    DEC (HL)

  • Administrator
  • 3,486 posts

Posted 16 August 2017 - 02:46 PM

Thanks for an interesting analysis and pictures, Andy! :)

Most welcome. :)

 

I felt it worth climbing this topic a bit (pun intentional!) at the time,


Changing order to chaos since 1984





Also tagged with one or more of these keywords: tree, questions, banyan, jsw

0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users